Is system design difficult?

Yes, system design can be considered difficult, especially for engineers who are new to the field or have limited experience designing large-scale, distributed systems. The complexity comes from the need to understand and balance several factors like scalability, reliability, availability, performance, and cost. Here’s why system design can be challenging:

1. Dealing with Scalability and Performance

In system design, you're often required to build systems that can handle millions or even billions of users, which is significantly more complex than designing for a single server or a small application.
Designing scalable systems involves understanding load balancing, horizontal scaling, sharding, and other techniques to distribute data and traffic efficiently.

2. Handling Trade-offs

You often have to make difficult trade-offs between conflicting goals like latency and throughput, or availability and consistency (as described by the CAP theorem).
Every decision in system design comes with trade-offs, and understanding how to balance those trade-offs in the context of the problem you’re solving is challenging.

3. Distributed Systems Complexity

Modern large-scale systems are distributed systems, which add another layer of complexity. Distributed systems introduce problems such as network partitions, data replication, eventual consistency, and fault tolerance.
Debugging and managing distributed systems is much harder than working on monolithic applications because of these extra layers of complexity.
Source: System Design Primer

4. Unfamiliarity with Components

Understanding how to properly use different components like databases (SQL vs. NoSQL), caching, message queues, and CDNs can be tough for those without experience in large-scale systems.
Designing systems with these components requires knowledge of when and how to apply each one, along with its strengths and limitations.

5. Lack of Clear Right Answer

Unlike coding problems where there is often a "correct" answer, system design problems are more open-ended. There are often multiple valid approaches, and success depends on your ability to justify your design decisions based on the context and constraints.
This ambiguity can make system design more intimidating.

Conclusion:

System design is considered difficult because it requires a deep understanding of multiple components, trade-offs, and scalability issues. For engineers transitioning from regular coding tasks to system architecture, mastering system design requires time, practice, and familiarity with distributed systems and real-world constraints.

Sources: